Skip to content
Emotesy — Child and Family Counseling Services
All writing

Why your toddler always picks the second thing you said

Early childhood

A study by Sumner, DeAngelis, Hyatt, Goodman and Kidd (2019) suggests that toddlers are more susceptible to recency bias, meaning they choose based on the most recently presented information. Adults tend to lean the other way, toward primacy bias.

Toddlers aged one to two chose the second option roughly 71% of the time when they were asked an “or” question, such as “Should Rori bring a backpack or a lunchbox to school?” The pattern held even when the researchers used nonsense words.

Two details make this more interesting than it first looks. The second-choice preference only showed up in verbal answers. When children pointed to indicate a preference instead, there was no meaningful difference between the first and second option. And the bias faded with age: three and four year olds showed no such pattern.

The researchers propose that limited working memory in toddlers is the culprit. Showing choices visually lowers the cognitive load, so the brain can hold both options at once rather than relying on memory alone.

The practical takeaway: when you offer your toddler an either-or choice out loud, say the one you are hoping for last.

Sumner, E., DeAngelis, E., Hyatt, M., Goodman, N., & Kidd, C. (2019). Cache cache: Children’s preference for the second option.

Written by the team at Emotesy Child and Family Counseling Services.

Sound like your house?

If the thing you just read describes your week, a phone call is a reasonable next step. We will tell you honestly whether we can help.

Call the practice

(425) 305-4360

Tell us what is happening and we will tell you if we can help.

Or send a message